Available in 9 inch, 8 inch and single serve unless otherwise specified.
Apple- Made with local apples
Peach- Made with local peaches
Cherry- Sour cherries
Blueberry- Wild blueberries
Strawberry Rhubarb- Made with local rhubarb
Raisin– 8 inch and single serve
Lemon Sponge- Two layer custard pie
Shoofly- Wet bottom molasses based pie
Montgomery- Lemon flavored two layer pie
Key Lime- 8 inch
Peanut Butter- 9 inch
Cheesecake- 8 inch
Available by special order unless specified.
French Apple- Raisins, apple (local) and a drizzle on top
Black Raspberry- Made with local raspberries (June – July)
Coconut Cream- Meringue top (all major holidays)
Chocolate Cream- Meringue top (all major holidays)
Lemon Meringue- (All major holidays)
Fresh Strawberry- (January – May)
Pumpkin- (September – December)
Egg Custard- (February – Easter)
Coconut Custard- (February – Easter)
Raspberry Custard- (Available during fresh raspberry season)
Mincemeat- (November – December)
Available in packs of 3 or single serve.
Chocolate with Vanilla Filling
Chocolate with Peanut Butter Filling
Pumpkin with Vanilla Filling
Red Velvet with Vanilla Filling- seasonal
DUMPLINGS & CRISPS
Made with local fruit.
Apple Dumplings- (August-February)
Peach Dumplings- (June-August)
Apple Crisp- (August-February)
Available in ½ dozens or packs of 2.
Soft Sugar with Chocolate Chips
Irish Shortbread- 8 oz packs
Sandtarts- Available by the dozen
Iced Sugar Cookies- Single
Pumpkin with Caramel Glaze- (October-November)
Available December only by the dozen.
Peanut Butter Blossoms
Dusted Brownie Cookies
Triple Chocolate Morsel
Black Walnut Tea Cookies
Cheesecake Cookies- Made with store made jams.
Chocolate Covered Cherry Cookies
Rollin’ in Walnut Cookies
Christmas Cookies also available in:
2 dozen or 3 dozen assorted tins
5 dozen or 10 dozen assorted trays
Available by the loaf or single serve.
Zucchini Nut & Raisin
Pumpkin Nut & Raisin
Sourdough Raisin Bread- By Order
Raisin Bread With Icing- By Order
Rye Sourdough- By Order
Dark German Rye- By Order
1 Dozen Dinner Rolls- By Order
Sandwich Rolls- By Order
OLD FASHIONED BREAD PUDDING
Made fresh daily.
Sticky Buns- Plain or with English walnuts (Pans of 8, ½ dozen mini or single serve).
Iced Cinnamon Rolls- Pan of 8 or single serve.
Cinnamon Twists- Dozen, ½ dozen, single.
Cheese & Cherry Cheese Danish
Friday and Saturday Only
Glazed, Cinnamon Sugar, Powdered Sugar and Plain
Buttercream Filled or Unfilled
Our donuts are the old Pennsylvania Dutch Fastnachts! Fastnachts are a potato donut that are traditionally eaten plain and dipped in Molasses. The tradition includes being made on Fat Tuesday to remove all starches from the house leading into Lent.
8 inch square or single serve.
Chocolate- Peanut Butter, Buttercream or Chocolate Frosting.
Vanilla- Chocolate or Buttercream Frosting.
Carrot with Walnuts- Cream Cheese Frosting.
Coconut- Buttercream Frosting.
Red Velvet- Seasonal or special order.
Spice- Clove & cinnamon (seasonal or special order).
Black Walnut- Special order only, price will vary.
We have a selection of premade rosette style decorated cakes available in store.
6 inch double layer- Serves 8-10
8 inch double layer- Serves 16-20
Special Orders start at $25 (72 hour notice required). Please call us at
717-218-5258 for pricing and to place your order.
Sorry- We do not make Wedding Cakes.
Available by the ½ dozen in store.
Special Order- Start at $15 a dozen
Mini Cupcakes- Start at $10 a dozen (By Order).
Available in a large or small loaf. Selection varies by the season.
Banana Nut with Chocolate Chips
Pumpkin with Chocolate Chips
Apple with Pecans & Cinnamon Glaze
Cherry Pudding- Vanilla with whole cherries.